A growing number of AFL players are being accused of exaggerating contact to win free kicks, sparking debate over whether the tactic is undermining the integrity of the game.
What was once considered a smart way to gain an advantage is now drawing comparisons to soccer-style diving, with fans, commentators and former players calling for stronger action from umpires and the AFL to curb the practice.
The AFL is experiencing mounting pressure as a growing number of players are ‘milking’ plays to earn free kicks and 50 metre penalties; a tactic critics say is the beginning to undermine the integrity of the game.
This controversy flared up after a contentious 50 metre penalty in the Adelaide Crows clash with Collingwood on Saturday, gifting the pies valuable territory and a big momentum swing late in the game. The incident reignited a debate over AFL players ‘milking’ for free kicks, with growing concern from supporters and the greats that games are being swayed by exaggerated reactions and very questionable calls.
This issue isn’t limited to the elite level. It’s now being seen across local competitions on the south coast.
Bay and Basin Under-14s assistant coach Mr Gabe Sheriff comments on a growing concern that this behaviour being normalised among junior players, potentially shifting the culture of the game from resilience and fairness to manipulation.
“I think players are over-exaggerating a lot with how they put their hands up and lay on the floor,” Mr Sheriff said.
Jane Davis, mother of former GWS Giants player Phil Davis, offered her perspective on the growing issue in the game.
”It would definitely trickle down to the younger levels because, as you say, you see it on TV. Kids are naturally going to want to copy or mimic what their idols in the league are doing especially if it helps them win a match,” Ms Davis said.
As the parent of a former AFL player, Ms Davis witnessed this behaviour occur more than once, and her insight reinforces the idea that actions at the professional level are quickly mirrored in junior football.
Overall, we can see that this is becoming an unhealthy trend not only in professional AFL but also in the junior clubs as well. The AFL is under a lot of pressure to act before it becomes embedded in the sports culture.
